Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: 40-1=39
Hashkafah.com > Thinking Jewish > Gemara/Mishna Discussions > Moed
critic
Do Makkot and Shabbat have something in common that they both share the number of 39? Why are they both referred to as 40 minus 1?
Miketab
edited for pointless banter


This is according to Chabad, but only regarding the melachot.
And this one is from some other site, about why they'd relate.

If you don't feel like going through all of it, here are very short versions:

Chabad site:
Our sages explain: the fortieth labor is the "work of heaven" we do on Shabbat.
Building the Mishkan actually involves forty categories of creative work: the thirty-nine modes of constructive involvement with the physical world in which we engage during six days a week and which we cease on Shabbat; and the spiritual labor of Shabbat. The fortieth labor requires the cessation of the first thirty-nine, for this is the act of stepping out of, and above, our weekday Mishkan building; yet it is ultimately an indispensable component of the job of constructing a home for G-d in our physical lives.

Other site:
According to Rav Daniel, the Maharal of Prague tells us that the number 40 alludes to the very havayah (totality) of the Sabbath, and the very havayah of a person. The totality of the Sabbath, in the halachic sense, consists of 39 negative commandments (i.e. please don't do these creative activities) and one positive commandment (i.e. please REST YOURSELF), which equal 40. When someone commits a sin punishable by lashes, they might actually DESERVE 40 lashes according to the law… but, according to the Maharal, we only give that person 39 lashes because we don't want to nullify his very existence. 40 lashes would spiritually, if not physically, annihilate him completely.
Gabbe
For those of us with our feet on the ground, the Mishna was compiled from oral traditions, and since it is easier to remember numbers in relation to round numbers, numbers are often rounded off.
Miketab
QUOTE(Gabbe @ Jul 16 2005, 11:32 PM)
For those of us with our feet on the ground, the Mishna was compiled from oral traditions, and since it is easier to remember numbers in relation to round numbers, numbers are often rounded off.
[right][snapback]268480[/snapback][/right]

ist shver... not so sure, is "40 minus 1" easier than 39? I feel people would forget the "-1", which is an issue with Makkot, as someone who gives a 40th hit is considered to have assaulted.

By the way, in daf 75 or so, I believe the gemarra gives a reason (the last argument before one of the mishnas), but I don't have it with me anymore to check.

Any help?
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.