QUOTE(aishel @ Nov 2 2006, 08:44 PM) [snapback]697280[/snapback]
Either way, you're showing that the simcha is lessened. [/guess]
Could be. I have no idea.
If I had to guess why "we" (ie at least some, if not many) are stricter that even a mourner do at least some form of hakafot on simchat torah whereas on sukkot he stands without circling hoshanot, I would guess it's at least partially because hoshanot, and the simchah associated with them, are
only sourced in sha's, whereas the hakafot of simchat torah are sourced in
kabbalah.