It looks.. uh.. gross. Kinda clumpy and the liquid seperated.

Is this from overbeating? Or was it bad?

Happened a few times too many for me to rely on. It's not from overbeating. Adding in air did nothing to help whip it. Either it was bad or thawed incorrectly or something. A couple times it's been a gell-ish type of consistency

Mommy says it went bad. Think the store will take it back?

Rich = Spoiled

Duh.

Depends on the store. Can't hurt to try, but don't get your hopes up. And don't buy another Whip from there in a while.

if it gets thawed and then refrozen it dies, sometimes the stores leave it out a while.

I added some cocoa into it, are you sure it's nothing to do with that? Also I tasted it, and I know this stuff is normally all chemicals and awful for you, so what are spoiled chemicals gonna do to me??

I don't think its spoiled, just unwhipable. I think You will be fine.

Quick rich whip tip: I experimented with a hand blender to whip it. Result:It works but tastes like parsley.

often it's a batch from the store that could have been out of freezer and re-frozen or similar. My sister-in-law once bought a whole bunch and NONE of them worked. I ended up running to a different store and getting her the spray type at the last second.