Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Jewish Movie - One Night With The King
Hashkafah.com > Community > Opinions
Red Hare
It's about the Purim story, obviously - I rather liked it, but it was VERY Hollywood'd up - my main kvetches are that it had too many characters, too many actors, and it was over 2 hours long!
Elana
i read the book.

why is jewish? i dont' think the book's author is jewish (but i really don't remember)
Red Hare
The book? Megilas Esther?
Elana
QUOTE(Red Hare @ Nov 6 2007, 03:57 PM) *
The book? Megilas Esther?


rofl.gif should i doubt the authorship of THAT book?

no, i meant the book, based on which they made this movie (the cover of the book i had said there is a movie)

http://www.amazon.com/Hadassah-Night-King-...7831599-8924421
brianna
I posted a thread about this around Purim time.
Red Hare
Forgive my ignorance, but …. Why would anyone read this book? As compared to the megillah, that is?
Goldfish
QUOTE(Red Hare @ Nov 8 2007, 01:59 PM) *
Forgive my ignorance, but …. Why would anyone read this book? As compared to the megillah, that is?

I've read a couple of these biblical retelling books. I read another version of Esther (not this one) and it was pretty bad. I read the Ema'ot series by Orson Scott Card and it was pretty good. I read the Red Tent which I thought was awful. And then I kind of got sick of the genre.

When done well, I think these books flesh out the psychology of the stories; they also give a lot of nice period details.
Elana
QUOTE(Red Hare @ Nov 8 2007, 02:59 PM) *
Forgive my ignorance, but …. Why would anyone read this book? As compared to the megillah, that is?


why not? i don't take it as a halachic source or something. it's fiction, based on historical material. even though i usually have a hard time reading historical fiction (cause i can't know what's true and what's not), i enjoyed this book.
Red Hare
Oh….OK. Thanks for explaining it to me.
Red Hare
I checked out the Brooklyn and Manhattan libraries – it’s not available in book form anymore ….

sad.gif


Goldfish
QUOTE(Red Hare @ Nov 15 2007, 03:11 PM) *
I checked out the Brooklyn and Manhattan libraries – it’s not available in book form anymore ….

sad.gif

Is too.
tasteslikechicken
it was nice and holywood, i watched it as an amusing movie, wouldn't let my children/students watch it though.

the problem was a few kids in my class had seen it, and said "morah we know the story, and then she had a necklace that showed the king that she was jewish", the girl who said that was 5...

oh well, i set her straight at the end though
Margaux
QUOTE(Goldfish @ Nov 8 2007, 02:15 PM) *
When done well, I think these books flesh out the psychology of the stories; they also give a lot of nice period details.


I agree. I enjoy the Ann Burton "Women of the bible" books.
Elana
QUOTE(Red Hare @ Nov 15 2007, 04:11 PM) *
I checked out the Brooklyn and Manhattan libraries – it’s not available in book form anymore ….

sad.gif


did you check the BPL online catalog? i read it not so long ago
Goldfish
QUOTE(Elana @ Nov 15 2007, 11:35 PM) *
did you check the BPL online catalog? i read it not so long ago

You're right, it's there too.
Red Hare
WOW, THANK YOU !!!!!
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.