Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Milchig Salad
Hashkafah.com > Misc. Advice & Help! > Cooking & Recipes
Pages: 1, 2
Elana
Something with veggies, not macaroni or potatoes.
greentiger
Greek?
BroadwayFreak
You can crumble feta cheese into most salads. Or cubes of cheese.
Red Hare
Add grated cheese to a veg. salad, no big whoop.
Elana
greek is probably the only one i know - leafy veggies, feta cheese, black olives. i do love it, but wanted something different.

oh, and another question:

5 (8oz) bars cream cheese

1. 8 oz cream cheese total, right?
2. i only know whipped or block cream cheese. if they mean latter, why 5 bars??
FYI
I once ate the yummiest real cheese salad. All different types of cheese, cubed and mixed together - it was yum! (why are we talking about this on a fast day?)
Elana
QUOTE(FYI @ Dec 19 2007, 11:54 AM) *
(why are we talking about this on a fast day?)


because today is the shabbos food shopping day. and i'll be picking up my daughter earlier from the daycare, so only 2 hours to decide what to make and what i should buy.

anyone - answers to the cream cheese questions? please?
BroadwayFreak
QUOTE(Elana @ Dec 19 2007, 11:43 AM) *
greek is probably the only one i know - leafy veggies, feta cheese, black olives. i do love it, but wanted something different.

oh, and another question:

5 (8oz) bars cream cheese

1. 8 oz cream cheese total, right?
2. i only know whipped or block cream cheese. if they mean latter, why 5 bars??


I don't really understand your question. I'm assuming "they" mean 5 bars b/c that's what the recipe calls for.
FYI
QUOTE(Elana @ Dec 19 2007, 11:04 AM) *
because today is the shabbos food shopping day. and i'll be picking up my daughter earlier from the daycare, so only 2 hours to decide what to make and what i should buy.

anyone - answers to the cream cheese questions? please?

oysh...isn't it hard to shop when you're hungry.
Are you making a milchig meal for shabbos?

QUOTE(BroadwayFreak @ Dec 19 2007, 11:11 AM) *
I don't really understand your question. I'm assuming "they" mean 5 bars b/c that's what the recipe calls for.

Me too - a total of 40 oz. Is this for a cheesecake?
Elana
oy, 5 blocks of cream cheese? you are probably right, didn't think it's would need so much; expensive - ouch! why didn't they put (8oz EACH)?!!!

yes, for a cheesecake (not sure any more i'll make it...)

milchig shabbos.
Red Hare
a mjilchiga shabos? you have milchigs bechers and nice dishes and servign stuff?
FYI
QUOTE(Red Hare @ Dec 19 2007, 01:22 PM) *
a mjilchiga shabos? you have milchigs bechers and nice dishes and servign stuff?

do you eat milchig on shavous? What becher do you use for kiddush?
Red Hare
We eat the milchigs in shul and then come home for fleishigs. Thank you for asking.
FYI
QUOTE(Red Hare @ Dec 19 2007, 02:21 PM) *
We eat the milchigs in shul and then come home for fleishigs. Thank you for asking.

I was wondering what kos is used for kiddush in these circumstances.
Red Hare
no idea. why?

for shavous youare supposed to have milchigs. a regular shbbos, you doh't have to.

perhaps the halacha is more lenient in that case.
agent220
Why can't your kos be pareve?
FYI
QUOTE(agent220 @ Dec 19 2007, 02:56 PM) *
Why can't your kos be pareve?

that was my point smile.gif
Red Hare
it's on the table and washed with fleishigs. is it really pareve?
agent220
It's kept on the table after the food is brought out?
You can't use a fleishig kli with a cold drink when on a milchig tablecloth?
Gosh, I sound like an apikorus!
Kalashnikover_Rebbe
I have an even wilder idea....
Use a glass....

While I cringe at the thought of a milchig Shabbos (although one meal might not be so terrible and I hear some Sefardim/Temanim do it in the summer), I really don't see any blatant halachic issues....

Besides if you are already eating milchigs, it shows you don't have the proper respect for Shabbos, and not using fancy china is no big deal...
Shuli
QUOTE(Red Hare @ Dec 19 2007, 04:25 PM) *
it's on the table and washed with fleishigs. is it really pareve?


How is it not?

QUOTE(Kalashnikover_Rebbe @ Dec 19 2007, 07:02 PM) *
Besides if you are already eating milchigs, it shows you don't have the proper respect for Shabbos, and not using fancy china is no big deal...


Hmm...what about vegetarian shabbosim? tongue.gif
Kalashnikover_Rebbe
QUOTE(Shuli @ Dec 20 2007, 03:05 AM) *
Hmm...what about vegetarian shabbosim? tongue.gif

Muktzeh machmas Mius....
Red Hare
you want milchigs, eat them all week. but shabbos ?
Kalashnikover_Rebbe
QUOTE(Red Hare @ Dec 20 2007, 04:37 AM) *
you want milchigs, eat them all week. but shabbos ?

To be honest I'd prefer a good milchig meal to some crappy roast chicken. But I agree that fleishigs done right is no comparison....
Margaux
QUOTE(Kalashnikover_Rebbe @ Dec 19 2007, 09:46 PM) *
To be honest I'd prefer a good milchig meal to some crappy roast chicken. But I agree that fleishigs done right is no comparison....



How about some broiled goat?
Kalashnikover_Rebbe
QUOTE(Gretchen @ Dec 20 2007, 05:49 AM) *
How about some broiled goat?

Believe it or not, I don't think I've ever actually eaten goat. (maybe once)...
Pinchas
אין שמחה אלה בשר ויין
greentiger
Yum, I would love a milchig shabbos meal. Especially in the summer, you can have an early milchig meal and then do fleishigs for seuda shlishis.
Pinchas
I never realized there were so many heretics on this site.
greentiger
QUOTE(Pinchas @ Dec 20 2007, 03:11 PM) *
I never realized there were so many heretics on this site.

How would be having milchigs for the main meal and fleishigs for seuda shlishis be any different than doing things the other way around (which seems to be quite widespead)?
Pinchas
QUOTE(greentiger @ Dec 20 2007, 01:27 PM) *
How would be having milchigs for the main meal and fleishigs for seuda shlishis be any different than doing things the other way around (which seems to be quite widespead)?


Gals just don't don't get it...

ya just don't mess with chulent! Chulent is sacred!
Elana
hee-hee, i knew i'll start a war with my milchig shabbos.

i hardly ever eat fleishig, chicken soup aside (last shabbos was the first in a long time i made chicken; usually i make something fleishig in a crock pot about once a month). mostly it's pareve shabbosim.

so, milchig shabbos it is smile.gif i love milchig stuff!

RH - many people eat milchig at home on shvuos, after making kiddush, and then 30 mins till the fleishig seuda - i've seen it very often.
NY-LON
KR, you sound like my husband - if there's no meat it's not a meal! though luckily fish is allowed....

don't see why a nice fish meal isn't shabbosdik (especially for Saturday lunch in summer) and then you can have a really rich dessert.
notreallyhere
QUOTE(greentiger @ Dec 20 2007, 06:27 AM) *
How would be having milchigs for the main meal and fleishigs for seuda shlishis be any different than doing things the other way around (which seems to be quite widespead)?

Because the main meal is supposed to be your main meal. It's like when people eat a split meal on Shabbos which comes out on YT, and eat their fish in the first meal, and their cholent in the second meal. My Rav doesn't approve of that.
melech
QUOTE(notreallyhere @ Dec 20 2007, 01:48 PM) *
Because the main meal is supposed to be your main meal. It's like when people eat a split meal on Shabbos which comes out on YT, and eat their fish in the first meal, and their cholent in the second meal. My Rav doesn't approve of that.

Yup. There's an inyan that the "second meal" [where the Friday night meal is the first meal] be the main meal as opposed to seudah shelishit.
(I'm not sure what that has to do with a shabbos YT, however, since that would apply every shabbos, although if Sunday is YT, then there's the additional problem of eating a big meal erev YT close to YT).

Note as well that's one of the problems of treating kiddush in shul like a meal and then counting lunch as seudah shelishit.
notreallyhere
QUOTE(melech @ Dec 20 2007, 02:26 PM) *
Yup. There's an inyan that the "second meal" [where the Friday night meal is the first meal] be the main meal as opposed to seudah shelishit.

Gosh, I'm breathing again. As I was putting my post up, I was thinking that melech is going to come along and prove me wrong. smile.gif

QUOTE(melech @ Dec 20 2007, 02:26 PM) *
(I'm not sure what that has to do with a shabbos YT, however, since that would apply every shabbos, although if Sunday is YT, then there's the additional problem of eating a big meal erev YT close to YT).

People do a split meal when it's Shabbos and then YT that night, so instead of eating a Shabbos meal at like 12, then seudas shlishis at 6, and then the YT meal at 9, they'll eat a split meal in the early afternoon.

QUOTE
Note as well that's one of the problems of treating kiddush in shul like a meal and then counting lunch as seudah shelishit.

Absolutely.
Elana
ok, guys, no one is allowed to bash my milchig shabbos (i wouldn't even think of doing it for a man, so relax) in my thread smile.gif

here is the question (too lazy to make a new thread).

this dish would be hamotzi, right?
melted butter, slices of bread, tomatoes, some yummy milchig stuff, slices of bread, shredded cheese.
melech
QUOTE(notreallyhere @ Dec 20 2007, 02:29 PM) *
People do a split meal when it's Shabbos and then YT that night, so instead of eating a Shabbos meal at like 12, then seudas shlishis at 6, and then the YT meal at 9, they'll eat a split meal in the early afternoon.

Oh. Thanks for explaining.

When do the kids eat if there's no seudah shelishit at 6...they wait till after shul at 9 or 10 and sit down to soup and fish and roast and tzimmis and kugel?
notreallyhere
QUOTE(melech @ Dec 20 2007, 02:38 PM) *
Oh. Thanks for explaining.

When do the kids eat if there's no seudah shelishit at 6...they wait till after shul at 9 or 10 and sit down to soup and fish and roast and tzimmis and kugel?

In my house, everything's very shleppy, so it's more like first meal at 1 (serve fish, cholent, maybe cold cuts). That lasts until 2. Then a break for officially half an hour but usually ends up being more like an hour. So the next meal starts at 3 (serve liver, salads). Ends at 4. Then you get to take a nap for two hours if you're lucky. [All times are approximate of course.] We don't really have kids in my house, but if there are kids....I don't know. Their mothers find something to serve them while the men are in shul? Since it's YT, you can warm something up for the kids who aren't old enough to be staying up for the meal.
Kalashnikover_Rebbe
QUOTE(melech @ Dec 20 2007, 09:26 PM) *
Note as well that's one of the problems of treating kiddush in shul like a meal and then counting lunch as seudah shelishit.

You DON'T do that, the whole chiddush is you can be mekayim SS BEFORE the second meal... Otherwise you would have to wash for kiddush anyway...
melech
QUOTE(Kalashnikover_Rebbe @ Dec 20 2007, 03:49 PM) *
You DON'T do that, the whole chiddush is you can be mekayim SS BEFORE the second meal... Otherwise you would have to wash for kiddush anyway...

If one isn't washing for kiddush in shul, I would think, in my humble opinion, that would be even more problematic to treat it as the second seudah and then your lunch as seudah shelishit, even if your lunch is after chatzot.
Elana
sad.gif
Kalashnikover_Rebbe
QUOTE(melech @ Dec 20 2007, 11:02 PM) *
If one isn't washing for kiddush in shul, I would think, in my humble opinion, that would be even more problematic to treat it as the second seudah and then your lunch as seudah shelishit, even if your lunch is after chatzot.

That's why it's a chiddush... smart.gif
Pinchas
BTW, just as is assur to have shabbos lunch without chulent it's assur to have SS without herring.
melech
QUOTE(Kalashnikover_Rebbe @ Dec 20 2007, 04:06 PM) *
That's why it's a chiddush

smile.gif
notreallyhere
QUOTE(Elana @ Dec 20 2007, 04:02 PM) *
sad.gif

I'm sorry, should we take this hijacking conversation elsewhere?

I'm confused. What's K-Rebbe saying? You can eat seudas shlishis before the second meal? blink.gif
Kalashnikover_Rebbe
QUOTE(notreallyhere @ Dec 20 2007, 11:13 PM) *
I'm confused. What's K-Rebbe saying? You can eat seudas shlishis before the second meal? blink.gifI'm sorry, should we take this hijacking conversation elsewhere?

Yes, provided it is after chatzos and you "have it in mind" to be mekayim the mitzvah on cake or peiros or whatever...
Elana
QUOTE(notreallyhere @ Dec 20 2007, 04:13 PM) *
I'm sorry, should we take this hijacking conversation elsewhere?


hijack as much as you want, just answer my question!! bigcry.gif
Pinchas
QUOTE(Kalashnikover_Rebbe @ Dec 20 2007, 11:15 PM) *
Yes, provided it is after chatzos and you "have it in mind" to be mekayim the mitzvah on cake or peiros or whatever...


What if you washed... could that still be S.S?
notreallyhere
QUOTE(Elana @ Dec 20 2007, 04:15 PM) *
hijack as much as you want, just answer my question!! bigcry.gif

About milchig salads? Most of the real caesar salad recipes are milchigs. I really don't know though.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.