Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: A Drink A Day For Longer Life
Hashkafah.com > Hock > News
The Rabbi
See article here

QUOTE
LONDON (Reuters) - Drinking is healthy, exercise is healthy, and doing a little of both is even healthier, Danish researchers reported on Wednesday.
ADVERTISEMENT
click here

People who neither drink nor exercise have a 30 to 49 percent higher risk of heart disease than people who do one or both of the activities, the researchers said in the European Heart Journal.

"The main finding is there seems to be an additional beneficial effect of drinking one to two drinks per day and doing at least moderate physical activity," said Morten Gronbaek of the University of Southern Denmark, who led the study.

Several major studies have found that light to moderate drinking -- up to two drinks a day on a regular basis -- is associated with a lower risk of heart disease, and some have also found this leads to a lower risk of some cancers.

But the Danish study, one of the largest of its kind to examine the combined effect of drinking and exercise, found there were additional protective effects gained from doing both.

The researchers collected information on the drinking and exercise habits of nearly 12,000 men and women aged 20 years or older between 1981 and 1983.

Over the next 20 years, some 1,200 of the participants died from heart disease and about 5,900 died from other causes.

Non-drinkers had a 30 percent to 31 percent higher risk of heart disease compared to moderate drinkers, no matter the amount of physical activity they undertook. Moderate consumption was defined as between 1 to 14 drinks per week.

But teetotallers who exercised at least moderately were able to reduce their risk of heart disease, an important finding for people who abstain because of religious beliefs or other health issues such as pregnancy, the researchers said.

People who had the lowest risk of dying from any cause were physically active, moderate drinkers while those at highest risk were the physically inactive, heavy drinkers, the study found.
krumlikeapretzel
They haven't shown causality in the study. I personally suspect that alcohol is not 
necessarily healthy, rather that moderate drinkers tend to be much better 
psychologically and socially adapted than either alcoholics or teetotallers.
The Rabbi
By that logic you also couldn't show that exercise would be beneficial to one's health. Maybe people who jog are just happier?
krumlikeapretzel
QUOTE(The Rabbi @ Jan 9 2008, 05:16 PM) *
By that logic you also couldn't show that exercise would be beneficial to one's health. Maybe people who jog are just happier?

Definitely
sephardic-male
this bogus study has been released couple of times in the last few months. why is this the alcohol related study released more often? could it be that liquor companies are only interested in increasing profits? 50 years ago big tobacco said smoking was healthy. how is this different from greedy liquor companies putting out alcohol benefits study every 3 months
shaya_getzl
QUOTE(krumlikeapretzel @ Jan 9 2008, 11:09 AM) *
They haven't shown causality in the study. I personally suspect that alcohol is not
necessarily healthy, rather that moderate drinkers tend to be much better
psychologically and socially adapted than either alcoholics or teetotallers.


Why can't it be accepted that alcohol in moderation has health benefits ?
sephardic-male
QUOTE(shaya_getzl @ Jan 21 2008, 04:44 PM) *
Why can't it be accepted that alcohol in moderation has health benefits ?



there are no health benefits from drinking liquor.
sephardic-male
Health benefits of booze in doubt
Sad fact is that alcohol can kill in myriad ways
Sharon Kirkey , CanWest News Service
Published: Friday, December 21, 2007
All it takes is a few drinks and ordinary, peaceful Canadians are willing to give electric shocks to strangers who annoy them.

In one of the darker sides of alcohol, lost in the mantra that moderate drinking wards off an early cardiac death, scientists at Toronto's Centre for Addiction and Mental Health say experimental evidence shows that alcohol in low doses makes people more prone to deliver an electric shock -- a pretend one -- to someone in a neighbouring lab room.

It is not something the beer and wine industry is likely to heartily endorse. Neither is the fact that, as our per capita consumption of alcohol increases, so too will our suicide and homicide rates; or that booze is implicated in about half of all fatal car crashes; that it can leave people disfigured from lip and mouth cancer; that it increases the risk of a fatal, hemorrhagic stroke or that it can kill or cause disease or injury in 49 other ways.



Experts say the flurry of headlines on the purported health benefits of "moderate" drinking has been a coup for the industry and led growing numbers of Canadians to think that if one drink is good, three or four is better.




Researchers say many studies that suggest moderate drinking can extend life are flawed in fundamental ways, lumping former heavy drinkers with health problems, for example, into the "abstainers" group, or ignoring the fact that moderate drinkers tend to be moderate people in lots of other ways.

They're more likely to exercise, eat their vegetables and cut the fat off their bacon, says Tim Stockwell, of the Centre for Addiction Research of B.C. In other words, "moderate drinking is a sign of good health, not a cause of good health."



http://www.canada.com/topics/bodyandhealth...43-5955b8460706




Deceptions in Reporting the Alcohol Benefit - When the media reports a study showing alcohol consumption as health benefit by decreasing risk of a heart attack, I would encourage the reading of the original study and the editorial comments to get an accurate assessment. In the New England Journal of Medicine (January 9, 2003), there was a study that attributed alcohol use to a reduced risk of a heart attack. In the editorial comments in this same issue, by Ira J. Goldberg, MD, there were some revealing facts about this study that were not mentioned in the media. Those in the non-alcoholic group had less physical activity, smoked, lower vitamin E intake, more diabetes, a higher intake of trans-and saturated fat and most importantly some had a past history of drinking, some of them heavily, before quitting. Also Dr. Goldberg wondered if the alcohol-consuming groups might have other lifestyle factors associated with reduced risk. He said, “not everything fits,” as alcohol does not reliably reduce arteriosclerosis in animals. The toxic effect of alcohol is well established, whereas the data on alcohol and cardiovascular disease is not. Another media report said that wine was associated with better lung function. However, the researchers in this study attributed the improvement to the antioxidants in the wine, not the actual wine itself and not the alcohol, and they warned of the harms of the alcohol in the wine. In fact, valid studies show that wine consumption makes the lung liable to injury and increases the risk of allergic reactions. These following facts are also missing from media reports: in 2000, our government declared alcoholic beverages to be a class “A” human carcinogen, along with arsenic and asbestos.

http://whyalcoholisbad.com/DebunkingtheBenefits.html


but hey let the corporations tell you how to live your life based on flawed studies and propaganda



sephardic-male
the worlds oldest living people NEVER drink liquor


http://whyalcoholisbad.com/Livingto100.html
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.